|
Post by mentalguru on Sept 9, 2010 11:04:36 GMT -5
People didn't always have surnames in every part of the world. And in Europe when they decided to bring them in there would be various ways with which they'd grant you one. The most basic example would be those ending in '-son' as in that person was the 'son' of someone. Sometimes they'd use objects or things in the area they lived. Other times they sometimes had names relating to an occupation.
For instance, my surname (last name) is an occupation itself, so it seems possible that waaaay back, an ancestor on my father's side held that occupation. My mother's surname is a different language but it apparently means something the lines of 'raven of peace'.
But I've looked around a bit and the name 'Waternoose' doesn't seem to be around anywhere. Feeling a little annoyed, I decided to split the name up a little to see if I got further. The closest I got to was a name called 'Waters' which was 'given to one who navigated the waters, or resided near them'. Possibly interesting.
There doesn't seem to be anything relating to the 'Noose' part, but if we consider possible occupations and perhaps a unique monster surname which never formed in our world or at least not with humans, could the idea be like an executioner or someone who held that job? Or someone who lived near gallows. Perhaps two families, one whose ancestors either lived near water (or navigated it) and the other who had an executioner/lived near gallows as an ancestor combined their names when the two families came together for some reason.
This has happened in history before with humans anyway, where two surnames come together and become that families surname which further ancestors will always hold through the male line except in extenuating circumstances (unlike in Spain etc. where they change things around every generation). In fact where I used to be a tour guide, a man combined both his mother's surname AND the one he recieved from his father in order to inherit the property (since only males holding his mother's surname could inherit it to begin with and both his Uncle's were dead by that stage). Of course he had a '-' in between, but perhaps over time Waters- Noose became Waternoose, because names can change over time for various reasons. There also can be different variations of the name as well.
Just curious as to what you think about this idea. Kind of random to think about but the fact I couldn't find anything relating to Waternooses surname kind of bothered me when you could find it for other characters fairly easily.
|
|
|
Post by pitbulllady on Sept 9, 2010 17:31:12 GMT -5
It's likely that the name IS a sort of combo of two different family names, which was common in the "old days", with some spelling changes from the original. "Waters" is, of course, a common surname, but the closest I can find to the "Noose" part, with regards to names, is "Neuse", a Germanic surname, so it would appear that the two names were combined. It was not at all uncommon when immigrants came to the US for the immigration officials who processed them at ports of entry like Ellis Island and Charleston to get confused as to how to spell or pronounce the newcomer's last names, and with many of the immigrants not being able to speak English, they couldn't correct them. As a result, on many official family immigration records, the names were mispelled, usually going with the phonetic spelling, and just never got changed. Also, during WWI, many Americans of German descent deliberately changed the spelling of their last names or even changed the names entirely to avoid the stigma that went with anything remotely German. The same thing happened in Great Britain, to some extent, which is why German Shepherd Dogs are still most often called "Alsatians" and why German Mastiffs are known in both the US and Britain as "Great Danes".
It's also possible that Pixar DID intend to have a darker meaning behind that name, as in a hangman's noose, or a noose that one uses to take one's own life, slowly strangling, a snare you can't escape from. Water can be both a sustainer of life AND a taker, so there seems to be some symbolism there, as well.
pitbulllady
|
|
|
Post by RandallBoggs on Sept 9, 2010 17:39:15 GMT -5
Of course, and I should be credited for this, if one recalls the comics, "Waternoose Gate" was mentioned. So perhaps Waternoose is a facsmile of, or some part of, the original referrance.
|
|
|
Post by mistica0christina on Sept 9, 2010 21:35:46 GMT -5
Okay, I officially don't get this topic....surname means last name so why call a last name a surname....I know that for my last name, nothing special cause it's just like all of the other common hispanic last names out there....so...yeah but as far as that guy in Spain you were talking about? Just sounds like he basically add a dash in his name cause normally most spanish speaking people or hispanics and such, our whole name is as follows First name, middle name (assuming if you were given one), your mother's maiden name and then your father's maiden name. For someone who is hispanic or of a spanish speaking blood or such, that is actually what your full name is known by.
|
|
|
Post by mentalguru on Sept 10, 2010 2:11:02 GMT -5
Not to be snarky Mistica but the confusion probably stems from the fact I'm aware I'm not using American english. Surname IS a lastname. Surname=lastname. It's just a different way of describing the same thing. It's kind of like the confusion there were over flashlights versus torches once. (Basically you say flashlight, I say torch for the exact same item. I do not automatically think of thing that the use to scare away movie monsters by paranoid villagers. Oh we use that word too to describe that, but that's more or less what our brain jumps to is the modern version which uses batteries). It's like what you call fries we call chips and what you call chips we call crisps. (Confused yet? Technically what you call crisps is correct since you Americans INVENTED the tasty-yet-unhealthy things but I think we already had that word for something else anyway in the whole fries versus chips thing so that's why we call it something else) Over here we say SURNAME when you guys say lastname. They mean the same thing, and sure if you say the latter we'll get what you're talking about but surname is just the phrase we use in the UK and Ireland. And the guy who did that to gain the property at my old work wasn't Spanish at all, but I was just stating that it wasn't the same thing as people did at Spain, who if you want to be technical about it kind of have a different surname/lastname combination every generation it seems because of how they are created. Or at least that's what I was taught at least traditionally speaking. However this man's name change would not change again at all for subsequent generations which they would otherwise. Put it this way, let's call him G, his father's surname was 'A' his mother's was 'B', but only males with 'B' as a surname could get the property. So he changed G's surname 'A' to 'A-B' and every generation after that is 'A-B' unless they are a married female. It never changed again through the male line. It simply happened to inherit something, to get around the clause in a contract. In regards the whole thing about Waternoose Gate, I more see that as something which happened after the name, and just a play on it. Corruption and all that. Regarding changing the name I kind of feel it's more likely to happen the misspelling/spelling it as it sounds. It's a strange thing to think about but of course monsters were already out of our world by ww1 and 2 and monsters are capble of making their own decisions and it's not like they must follow some weird destiny thing which MUST mirror our own history. (The fact they gain energy the way they do certsainly accounts for that). It's more likely a mistake and possibly something they never knew to correct than something they delibrately changed just because it was German. Actually that's quite odd when you think about it. While I kind of think of Monstropolis as at least in the country 'in charge' or at the very least if not a superpower, being a 'great power' on Britian's level it's unlikely their history is 100% exactly the same. No Adolf Hitler. Or at least no-one walking round with that name who did the exact same things. Maybe they have no equivilant in the 20th century at all. Perhaps there is something which reached the level of his atrocities and could be seen as similar but NOT necessarily, and even if so it probably have been against and by different groups entirely and may have been started from a key of events entirely different to how it started in ours if it happened at all. WW2 history is strange. We studied at school Germany's side on the matter from when ww1 ended until just after ww2. Depressing stuff. It seems what got the ball rolling was revenge in the end. France wanted Germany to suffer after the first world war, and their anger was understandable since they'd suffered the most but due to the winners of the first world war failing, as well as things they couldn't control (depression) it became an ample atmosphere and opportunity for people like the Nazis to rise. America was real bad in the depression, but Germany was even worse given their bad position to beging with- France more or less destroyed them like that, especially since their money was tied up in Americas (loans and all to pay off the reperations) more than others in Europe. I quite like the idea they had a darker tone in mind for the name too. It's simply that it's an odd one really in the end and it doesn't exist in ours. Granted the fact that monster surnames are like ours at all is weird.
|
|
|
Post by mistica0christina on Sept 10, 2010 20:33:42 GMT -5
Okay, I get it, I'll shut up next time. All I asked was a simple question, if you didn't want to answer it then you didn't need to. Next time, I'll ask my mother.
Lol, I know we are trying not to be snarky here but here's how I feel, this is a clip from George Lopez's comedy, go ahead and scroll to the 2:08 and watch the bit about "fountain drinks" if you will.....here's what I'm getting at. ;D
|
|